Convening Power

As it is the weekend(!) I am affording myself the luxury of straying from the day-to-day of ColaLife to write down the things I’ve been saying about “Convening Power” during recent presentations (Royal Society of Medicine, TEDx Berlin) and how we’ve used this to get where we’ve got with the ColaLife project.

The term, Convening Power, has an intentional double meaning – there’s more to it than I first imagined.

Most individuals, and I include myself in this, have very little power but we all have some. But as individuals we generally don’t have enough power to get the attention of very powerful individuals or institutions. So what do we do? We put all our little bits of power together – we convene to aggregate our power – and approach those more powerful than ourselves as a group.

This was the primary reason for setting up the ColaLife Facebook Group* three years ago. I’d got nowhere trying to engage Coca-Cola as an individual so it was time to gather more people around the idea to give me more power. This is what trade unions have been doing for years and it is captured beautifully in this UNISON video – one of my favourite adverts of all time.

So there is nothing new in this sort of convening for power but what is new is that whereas before you needed an organisation – like a trade union – to do it, today anyone who knows how to use Facebook can do it. Today you succeed or fail more on the strength of your ideas and less on whether you have the might of an organisation behind you.

So what other sorts of power does convening give you? Before setting up the Facebook group I had had a very positive, I’d even say a life-changing, experience, with the process of open innovation. So I was aware that exposing the ColaLife idea at an embryonic stage would generate comment, challenge and suggested improvements to the idea and this indeed has happened. The original published idea was:

What about Coca Cola using their distribution channels (which are amazing in developing countries) to distribute rehydration salts? Maybe by dedicating one compartment in every 10 crates as ‘the life saving’ compartment?

That was never going to work and soon we came around to the idea of making use of the unused space between the necks of crated bottles instead of replacing one with a tube.

ColaLife pods in place Model AidPods in a Coca-Cola crate
What open innovation does. How the idea has developed by sharing it online.

If I’m honest that thought process – the idea of making use of the unused space – started in my own living room and came from Jane (my partner in life and ColaLife) – so you don’t have to have online systems to undertake open innovation but it does help. I’m sure she was stimulated by the online competition! Other improvements to the idea that have come from further afield include:

  • Insights into the way the Coca-Cola system and distribution chain works
  • The idea of the AidPod as a kit
  • The role of enterprise
  • The importance of local determination of how the concept is applied in a particular place
  • Ideas on how to increase credibility eg through our Virtual Advisory Board
  • Etc

Convening people around you and an idea increases your credibility. The higher your credibility the more power you have. Amongst our supporters are some of the most well respected experts in their fields. To highlight this fact we have asked these people to be part of our Virtual Advisory Board and make a public statement about their desire to see ColaLife piloted.

Another outcome of this convening process, which was unexpected, is the heightened sense of responsibility that it generates in you. When I went for that first meeting with Coca-Cola, way back in June 2008, it felt like the 1,000 members of the Facebook Group* were watching me. They weren’t all watching of course but that’s not important. The important thing is that it felt like they were watching. What that meant was that I gave a lot of thought to that meeting before I went in and in particular focused on what I might be able to take away for ColaLife supporters. I’ve attended many meetings in my life and always take them seriously but I had never felt that same level of responsibility before. This, perhaps, is more of a reflection on me than on the process of convening.

Then there is the power that comes with confidence. Exposing your idea to thousands of people and getting a largely positive reaction makes you realise that the idea may actually be quite a good one. You will never get 100% approval and we do not have this, but I can count the number of people who have said that the idea is NOT worth piloting on the fingers of one hand.

So whatever it is you are doing consider being open and sharing. This will give you various sorts of power and is likely to improve your idea and all of these things will help you get your idea implemented. It’s not always appropriate to take the open road of course but often it is. As Rowland Harwood of 100% Open said a couple of weeks ago at NESTA: ‘Default to open’.
Default to Open
Only keep things to yourself if you’ve got VERY VERY good reasons to do so.

* The ColaLife Facebook Group, which now has 8,420 members, has been superseded by our Facebook Page which has 4,240 members

ColaLife principle: openness

I first had the ColaLife idea in 1988 when I was working for the British Aid programme in NE Zambia. However, I was unable to share it other than by word of mouth and I got nowhere.

In May 2008 I shared the idea on Facebook and look what’s happened. Thousands of people have convened around the idea and discussed it and challenged it and the idea has got better and better. We have gone from this:

ColaLife aidpods tube Unicef ORS Sachet (front)

Removing one bottle from every 10 crates and replacing it with a cylinder full of Oral Rehydration Salts (ORS) to this:

ColaLife aidpod Wedge in place (cropped) Social products

A wedge-shaped container that uses the un-used space in a crate and carries whatever ‘social products’ are needed in a local area, as determined by the local public health experts.

So openness has convened thousands of people around the idea. This has improved the idea, given us more and more confidence in the idea and got Coca-Cola’s attention. We just need some action now!

Convening Power

Crate detail

I have a great debt of gratitude to those who joined us in the great Open Innovation Exchange (OIE) experiment which I ended up getting a lot of credit for but was really the brain child of David Wilcox et al. The Open Innovation Exchange developed a competitive bid for a UK Government contract in the open, online and the bid was much better as a result.

One thing was clear from the OIE experiment, and that was, that the more people you can convene around an idea the better the idea will become. It’s not that others necessarily come up with better ideas but they will challenge it and force those who put up the idea to improve it or let it die.

This is exactly what’s happened with ColaLife. The idea I put up in May 2008 was that Coca-Cola should remove one bottle in every 10 crates and replace it with a cylinder containing Oral Rehydration Salts (ORS). Now we are talking about a wedge-shaped container (not a cylinder) that makes use of the unused space in a crate AND with local determination of what goes on the container – ORS may not be what’s required in every location, all year round. We’ve gone from a good idea to a brilliant idea (IMHO) because of the way the idea has been exposed, discussed and challenged.

There are other benefits from this process and this became very apparent in the interview I’ve been through today (22/12/09) for the Buckminster Fuller Challenge. I was very relaxed going into the interview because I was pretty sure there wasn’t a question that they could come up with that I hadn’t been asked already by a ColaLife supporter in the discussion/challenge process that has gone on over the last 18 months. And that proved to be the case.

There are other benefits of convening of course:

  1. There’s the one that everyone knows. If you’re a lone voice, you are easy to ignore especially if you’re trying to get the attention of one of the biggest brands on the planet (Cola-Cola in our case). Lot’s people saying the same thing are more difficult to ignore and this has proved to be the case with ColaLife. We’ve managed to get Coca-Cola’s attention. A crucial first step in our case!
  2. If people convene around an idea it gives you huge confidence that the idea must be a good one. This is really important when you come to try and sell the idea to others (eg potential supporters) who have to be convinced.

As I have said before, this is why I believe in open innovation.

Onwards and upwards.

Why I’m very pleased to be speaking at Chain Reaction next week


Simon Berry on ColaLife and Chain Reaction

Colalife is a great idea. It’s not the idea it was a year ago. It’s much better. I’m a great believer in open innovation which is essentially the process of opening up of ideas to others so that they are made better (the ideas not the people). That’s why I’m so pleased to be contributing to Chain Reaction. It’s a valuable face to face opportunity to expose the ColaLife idea to another bunch of innovative people. These people will challenge the idea and ask difficult questions, many will be supportive and enthused. And this will result in the further honing of the idea and will further build confidence  which is essential if we are to make ColaLife, and all the other bright ideas that will be on display at Chain Reaction, a reality.

Have you booked for Chain Reaction yet by the way? You can do it hereit’s free if you’re under 21 – and if you’re not under 21 and have to pay, you’ll be providing an opportunity for the youngsters to be inspired by the amazing Chain Reaction programme.